Hannah Swensen, a newly married bakery proprietor, comes back from her honeymoon cruise only to find herself embroiled in a murder mystery in Lake Eden, Minnesota. As she looks forward to enjoying her new life as a wife, her plans are disrupted when Victoria Bascomb, a former stage actress and her mother’s neighbor, is discovered dead. With numerous adversaries and potential culprits, Hannah is tasked with uncovering the truth behind the murder while also dealing with her own personal challenges. Cracking the case and staying safe might prove to be more difficult than mastering her renowned banana cream pie.